Skip to main content

Guaranteed Returns: The Biggest Red Flag in Investments

Why the promise of high returns 'without risk' is a typical sign of fraud, how true guarantees (FDIC, EE bonds) differ from a seller's word, how to check an advisor on Investor.gov and BrokerCheck (and in Poland on KNF), and what to do if your money is already gone.

In Brief
  • Every investment carries risk. The promise of high returns 'without risk' is, according to the SEC, one of the typical signs of fraud.
  • True guarantees exist, but they are modest and have a specific guarantor: e.g., a deposit in a bank insured by the FDIC (up to $250,000) or EE savings bonds from the Department of the Treasury.
  • Before depositing money, check the seller on Investor.gov and FINRA BrokerCheck, and in Poland on the KNF public warning list.
  • If you have already deposited, report the matter as soon as possible: ic3.gov, ReportFraud.ftc.gov, and your bank.

"A steady 8% per year, zero risk, guaranteed capital." Such a statement can convince even the most cautious person, especially when said by someone from our parish, a Polish community group on Facebook, or a friend of a friend. Many investment scams rely on trust in 'your own.' Below, we explain why the word 'guaranteed' should raise a red flag, how true guarantees differ from marketing promises, and how to check an offer before you lose your savings.

What Guaranteed Returns Are

A guaranteed return is a promise that money will yield a steady, certain income regardless of what happens in the market. The seller usually emphasizes that this is a 'low-risk' offer, as this is what people who have worked hard for their savings are looking for.

The problem is that the market does not work that way. The SEC reminds us that every investment carries some risk, and the higher the potential return, the greater the risk usually is. Anyone promising both high returns and no risk either does not understand what they are selling or is deliberately misleading.

True Guarantee vs. Seller's Promise

Not every guarantee is false. There are products where a credible party truly takes on the risk. The difference lies in who guarantees and how high the return is.

ProductWho GuaranteesWhat to Watch Out For
Savings account or CD at a bank insured by the FDICThe federal agency FDIC insures deposits up to at least $250,000 per person, at one bank, in a given ownership categoryInsurance does not cover stocks, bonds, funds, annuities, cryptocurrencies, or treasury securities purchased by the bank
EE savings bondsThe U.S. Department of the Treasury guarantees that the bond will double in value after 20 yearsThe return is low, and you only get full guarantee after holding it for 20 years
A 'fund' from a friend, cryptocurrency platform, 'program' with 8% monthly or annuallyOnly the seller's wordNo independent guarantor, often no registration with the SEC or state regulator

If someone says 'I guarantee,' ask: who specifically guarantees, on what legal basis, and where can I check this? A lack of a clear answer is an answer.

Warning Signs According to the SEC

The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) publishes a list of warning signs on Investor.gov that should raise suspicions. These include:

  • seller without a license or registration,
  • aggressive seller boasting exaggerated or false qualifications,
  • an offer that sounds 'too good to be true',
  • an 'investment without risk' and promises of great wealth and guaranteed returns,
  • persuasion that 'everyone is already buying',
  • pressure to invest immediately,
  • sensational advertisements, often with fake testimonials from satisfied customers,
  • unsolicited contact where someone tries to extract your personal information,
  • request for payment by credit card, gift card, or wire transfer abroad or to a private account.

This last point connects to 'gift card' scams, which we describe in the guide How to Avoid Apple and Prepaid Gift Card Scams.

Common Returns in Such Offers

  • 'Guaranteed return on investment'
  • 'No risk', 'absolutely safe'
  • 'Steady profit of 8% per year' (or monthly)
  • 'This investment cannot lose value'
  • 'Invest now before it's too late'
  • 'We have a special algorithm, artificial intelligence predicts the market'
  • 'Don't tell anyone, this is an offer only for trusted individuals'

The mere phrase does not determine that it is a scam. But the more of them you hear in one conversation, the more cautious you should be regarding the entire offer. The FBI notes in its 2025 report that scammers increasingly use recordings and voices of well-known individuals generated by AI to legitimize 'investment clubs' on social media.

Why 'Low Risk, Guaranteed 8%' Doesn't Add Up

Financial markets go up and down. Even government bonds, considered very safe, change in price if you sell them before maturity. An investment that pays out equal returns every month regardless of the stock market situation looks suspicious precisely because it is so smooth.

The SEC describes this mechanism in Ponzi schemes. Organizers promise high returns with low risk, but often do not invest the money at all. Payments to earlier participants come from new deposits. Such a system requires a constant influx of cash, so it collapses when there are no new participants or when many people want to withdraw money at once. Among the SEC's warning signs are:

  • too regular returns, independent of the market,
  • investments not registered with the SEC or state regulator,
  • unlicensed sellers,
  • mysterious, complicated strategy that no one can explain,
  • errors in account statements,
  • trouble withdrawing money, or even pressure not to withdraw because 'staying earns a higher percentage.'

The Scale of the Problem in Numbers

These are not isolated cases. According to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), in 2025, consumers reported 3 million frauds and losses amounting to $15.9 billion. The most money, over $7.9 billion, was lost to investment scams.

FBI data is even higher. The IC3 center received over a million reports in 2025 with losses of $20.877 billion. Investment fraud was the category with the highest losses: $8.65 billion with 72,984 reports. Individuals over 60 reported total losses of $7.7 billion. This is a good reason to discuss this with parents and grandparents.

How to Check an Offer and Seller

Check the Person

Enter the advisor's name or the company's name in the search engine on Investor.gov (Investment Professional Background Check) or in FINRA BrokerCheck. You will see if someone has registration, where they worked, and if they have been disciplined. Lack of presence in the databases is a serious warning sign.

Check the State Regulator

Many offers fall under the supervision of the state securities regulator. You can find contact information for your state's office on the NASAA website (association of state regulators).

Offer from Poland

If someone proposes an investment from Poland or through a Polish company, check it on the KNF public warning list and in the entity search on the KNF website. The KNF warns that lack of an entity on the warning list does not mean it is credible.

Ask Questions and Wait

Request documents in writing, ask who guarantees the profit, and give yourself a few days. A legitimate offer will wait. A scammer will pressure you.

Common Mistakes

MistakeWhy It Harms
Believing in a 'guarantee' without asking who provides itA seller's guarantee is worthless if it is not backed by a bank with FDIC, the U.S. Treasury, or another real guarantor
Trusting because a friend or someone from a community group recommends itScammers deliberately operate in closed communities, and the first participants in a pyramid often sincerely recommend it further
Making a decision under time pressure'Offer valid until Friday' is meant to prevent you from checking the seller
Not checking on Investor.gov or BrokerCheckThis takes a few minutes and can save your savings
Paying a 'tax' or 'fee' to withdraw profitsThe FBI describes this as the last stage of a scam, after which the perpetrators disappear with the money

What to Do If You Have Already Deposited Money

  1. Stop depositing, even if the 'platform' shows profits or demands a fee for withdrawal.
  2. Immediately call the bank or institution through which you sent the money and request to stop or reverse the transfer.
  3. File a report with the FBI at ic3.gov. The FBI asks for reports regardless of the amount and as soon as possible.
  4. Report the matter to the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov, and if it involved securities, also to the SEC (under the 'Submit Questions and Complaints' tab on Investor.gov) and to the state regulator.
  5. Keep everything: messages, contracts, transfer confirmations, names of websites and accounts.
  6. Be cautious of 'money recovery' companies. The FBI warns that victims of investment fraud are then targeted by other scammers posing as law firms, officials, or even IC3 itself.

If the matter concerns Poland, report the internet incident to CERT Polska (incydent.cert.pl), and a crime to the police or prosecutor's office.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can any investment have a guaranteed return?

Yes, but then the guarantor is specific and verifiable, and the return is usually small. Examples include deposits in banks insured by the FDIC or EE savings bonds. High returns guaranteed by the seller themselves are a warning sign.

Is 8% per year always a scam?

No. The stock market can yield more in some years and incur losses in others. The suspicious part is the promise that 8% will always be guaranteed, without risk and regardless of market conditions.

How to check if an advisor is licensed?

Use the search engine on Investor.gov and FINRA BrokerCheck. Both tools are free. You can also ask the securities regulator in your state.

Someone promises to recover my money for a fee. What should I do?

Exercise extreme caution. The FBI records thousands of reports of 'money recovery' scams. Report the original fraud at ic3.gov and do not pay anyone upfront for the promise of recovering your money.

Sources

SourceTypeStatus / Credibility
SEC / Investor.gov: Red Flags of Investment Fraud ChecklistFederal agency (USA)Official, verified 10/23/2026
SEC / Investor.gov: Ponzi SchemeFederal agency (USA)Official, verified 10/23/2026
FDIC: Understanding Deposit Insurance (250,000 USD, what is not covered)Federal agency (USA)Official, verified 10/23/2026
TreasuryDirect: EE Bonds (doubling in value after 20 years)U.S. Department of the TreasuryOfficial, verified 10/23/2026
FBI IC3: 2025 Internet Crime ReportFBI ReportOfficial, verified 10/23/2026
FTC: Testimony before the Joint Economic Committee, 03/25/2026 (data for 2025)FTC DocumentOfficial, verified 10/23/2026
FINRA BrokerCheckSelf-regulatory organization (USA)Official tool
SEC: Investment Adviser Public DisclosureFederal agency (USA)Official tool
NASAA: Contact Your RegulatorAssociation of state regulatorsCredible
KNF: Public Warning ListSupervisory authority (Poland)Official, verified 10/23/2026
CERT Polska: Report an IncidentResponse team (Poland)Official

As of October 23, 2026. This guide is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, tax, or investment advice. Before making an investment decision, check the seller in official databases and, if in doubt, consult a licensed advisor.

Was this guide helpful?

Help others – share your experience

Answer one question below. Your answer will help people in similar situations.

Have you ever come across an investment offer that promised guaranteed returns with no risk? What were your impressions and what did you do in that situation?

Your response will be reviewed before publication.

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Be the first!


Add a comment

Log in to skip email verification, or comment as guest:

Comment may be moderated before publishing.