- The "4% rule" comes from William Bengen's 1994 study: withdrawing 4% of the portfolio in the first year, then adjusting that amount for inflation. Based on U.S. market data from 1926, such a portfolio has never depleted faster than 33 years.
- This is a historical observation, not a guarantee. The study assumed a specific portfolio (in the basic variant, half stocks, half U.S. Treasury bonds), tax-deferred accounts, and at least 30 years of withdrawals.
- Taxes must be deducted from the withdrawal amount. Withdrawals from a traditional IRA and 401(k) are ordinary income, and the IRA defaults to withholding 10% for federal tax.
- At age 73 (born 1951–1958) or 75 (from 1960), RMD applies. The minimum withdrawal is 3.77% of the balance at age 73 and increases with age. Failure to withdraw incurs a 25% tax on the missing amount.
- Flexibility helps: smaller withdrawals after a bad year reduce the risk of running out of money too soon.
You have saved money for retirement and want to know how much you can withdraw each year to last throughout your life. There is no single safe number, but there are good benchmarks. This guide explains the origin of the famous 4% rule, what the study really said, how taxes and RMD affect the withdrawal rate, and why a flexible plan is usually safer than a rigid one. The amounts and tax thresholds refer to the year 2026.
What is a Withdrawal Rate
The withdrawal rate is the annual amount you take from your savings divided by their value. If you have $600,000 and withdraw $24,000 annually, the withdrawal rate is 4%.
Important distinction: the 4% rule refers to the percentage calculated only once, based on the portfolio value in the first year of retirement. In subsequent years, you do not recalculate 4% but instead increase last year's amount by inflation, regardless of market conditions.
| Retirement Year | Withdrawal with a $600,000 Portfolio and 3% Inflation |
|---|---|
| 1 | $24,000 (4% of the portfolio) |
| 2 | $24,720 |
| 3 | Approximately $25,460 |
Before calculating how much you need from the portfolio, subtract certain income from your expenses: Social Security, ZUS pension, company pension. The portfolio should only cover the gap. With $60,000 in expenses and $36,000 from Social Security, you need $24,000 from savings, not $60,000. We discuss combining these sources in the guide planning retirement income for Poles in the USA.
Where the 4% Rule Came From
In October 1994, financial advisor William P. Bengen published an article titled "Determining Withdrawal Rates Using Historical Data" in the Journal of Financial Planning. He examined actual U.S. market data from 1926 to see how long a retiree's portfolio would last if they started retirement in subsequent years. Important assumptions included:
- a portfolio consisting of half large-cap stocks and half intermediate-term U.S. Treasury bonds (later in the study, other ratios were also considered),
- withdrawal in the first year as a percentage of the portfolio, then the same amount adjusted annually for inflation,
- regularly rebalancing to maintain the assumed proportions,
- all money in tax-deferred accounts, thus no capital gains tax.
Bengen's findings:
| First Year Withdrawal | What History Showed |
|---|---|
| 3% (and up to about 3.5%) | The portfolio always lasted at least 50 years |
| 4% | Never depleted before 33 years, usually lasted 50 years or longer |
| 4.25% | In the worst periods, it could deplete after 28 years |
Bengen advised his clients not to exceed 4% in the early years of retirement, especially when retiring at age 60 or earlier. He also noted that having less than 50% in stocks reduced both wealth and the minimum longevity of the portfolio in his data. He considered a reasonable range to be between 50% and 75% in stocks.
This study gave rise to the popular "4% rule," although the term itself does not appear in the article. The main limitations to keep in mind are:
- It is data from one country, with a very favorable 20th century for stocks. The future may look different.
- The study counted 30 years or more. A person retiring at age 55 may need money for longer.
- A portfolio with a lot of cash or very conservative investments yields different results than the portfolio in the study.
- The amount from the study is the withdrawal from the account, not the money after tax. We discuss taxes below.
Why the Beginning of Retirement is Most Important
With fixed withdrawals, the sequence of market returns has a huge impact. A 20% drop in the first year of retirement is much more damaging than the same drop after 15 years because you sell investments at low prices, leaving less money to benefit from a rebound. Bengen pointed out that the most destructive drop in his data occurred in 1973–1974, coinciding with high inflation. You can find a numerical example in the guide sequence of returns risk, and we discuss portfolio allocation before retirement in the guide growth or income before retirement.
Flexible Withdrawal Rules
The rigid rule assumes you withdraw the same amount plus inflation each year, even after a market crash. In practice, most people respond to the situation, and rightly so. Here are a few simple strategies retirees use:
- No increase after a bad year. If the portfolio has dropped, you do not increase the withdrawal for inflation in the following year.
- Ranges. You set a base amount and a minimum level for essential expenses. In good years, you can spend more; in bad years, you revert to the minimum.
- Percentage of current value. Each year, you withdraw the same percentage of the current balance. The money will never run out, but the annual amount can vary significantly.
- Cash reserve. You keep money for one or two years of withdrawals in a safe place to avoid selling stocks after a drop.
Advisors and planning programs often use Monte Carlo simulations, which involve thousands of random market scenarios. A result like "85% chance of success" is not a guarantee but an assessment based on the assumptions made. Ask what returns and inflation rates were assumed.
RMD: When the Law Requires You to Withdraw More
From traditional retirement accounts (Traditional IRA, SEP, SIMPLE IRA, 401(k), 403(b), and similar), you must withdraw at least the minimum amount, known as RMD (required minimum distribution), starting at a certain age. The starting age is:
- 73 for those born between 1951 and 1958,
- 75 for those born on or after January 1, 1960,
- for those born in 1959, the IRS has not yet finalized the rules, so check the current IRS position.
The first RMD can be deferred until April 1 of the following year, but then you will withdraw two RMDs in the same year, which increases your taxable income. Roth IRA and Roth accounts in 401(k) or 403(b) do not have RMD during the owner's lifetime.
The RMD is calculated by dividing the balance as of December 31 of the previous year by a factor from the IRS table (Uniform Lifetime Table). In percentage terms, it looks like this:
| Age | Factor | RMD as % of Balance | RMD on a $500,000 Balance |
|---|---|---|---|
| 73 | 26.5 | 3.77% | Approximately $18,870 |
| 75 | 24.6 | 4.07% | Approximately $20,330 |
| 80 | 20.2 | 4.95% | Approximately $24,750 |
| 85 | 16.0 | 6.25% | Approximately $31,250 |
| 90 | 12.2 | 8.20% | Approximately $40,980 |
This table applies to most individuals. If the only beneficiary of the account is a spouse more than 10 years younger, a different table and lower amounts apply.
What this means for the withdrawal rate:
- RMD is the minimum withdrawal from the account, not an obligation to spend the money. What you do not need can be invested after tax in a regular account. RMD cannot be rolled back into an IRA.
- After age 80, RMD exceeds 4% and continues to grow. With a large traditional IRA, taxes may force larger withdrawals than you planned.
- If you do not withdraw the full RMD on time, you pay a 25% tax on the missing amount (excise tax), and 10% if you correct the mistake on time, usually within 2 years. This is reported on Form 5329.
For more details, see the guides RMD: what it is and how it works and how to avoid large RMDs.
Taxes: Gross Withdrawal is Not Take-Home Money
The 4% rule refers to the withdrawal amount, not how much remains after tax. The most important rules in the U.S. are:
- Traditional IRA and 401(k): withdrawals are taxed as ordinary income (except for the portion already taxed). For one-time withdrawals from an IRA, the institution defaults to withholding 10% for federal tax. You can choose a different rate on Form W-4R.
- Before age 59.5, an additional 10% tax usually applies (with exceptions).
- Roth IRA: qualified withdrawals are tax-free. We describe them in the guide Roth IRA or Traditional IRA: which is better for you.
- Social Security: withdrawals from an IRA increase income, which affects whether benefits are taxed. Part of the benefits may be taxable when income plus half of the benefits exceed $25,000 (single) or $32,000 (married filing jointly). Above $34,000 and $44,000, up to 85% of benefits may be taxable.
- Additional deduction for seniors: in 2025–2028, individuals aged 65 and older can deduct an additional $6,000 ($12,000 if both spouses qualify). The deduction phases out at income (MAGI) above $75,000, and for joint filing above $150,000.
- Medicare: higher income may increase Medicare premiums due to the IRMAA surcharge. We describe it in the guide how IRMAA increases Medicare premiums.
Example: if you withdraw $24,000 from a traditional IRA, and your total tax rate on that amount is, for example, 12%, you will have about $21,100 left. Therefore, when planning withdrawals, calculate the after-tax amount, not before.
Common Mistakes and Myths
| Myth or Mistake | What is True |
|---|---|
| "4% is a guarantee that the money will last." | This is based on historical U.S. data with a specific portfolio and a period of about 30 years. Future results may be worse. |
| "I withdraw 4% of the current balance each year, so I am following the rule." | The rule from the study is 4% in the first year, then the amount adjusted for inflation. A percentage of the current balance is a different method. |
| "It is safest to have only bonds and cash." | In Bengen's study, having less than 50% in stocks reduced both wealth and the minimum longevity of the portfolio. Too little risk is also a risk. |
| "I must spend my RMD." | You must withdraw it, but you can invest the money after tax in a regular account. |
| "If I forget about RMD, it’s just a small penalty." | 25% on the missing amount, 10% if you correct the mistake quickly. |
| Calculating withdrawals without tax. | Withdrawals from traditional accounts are ordinary income and can increase taxes on Social Security and Medicare premiums. |
What You Can Do
- List your annual expenses and subtract certain incomes (Social Security, ZUS, company pension). The difference is the amount the portfolio should cover.
- Divide that amount by the value of your savings. A result above 4–5% is a signal that the plan is tight.
- Decide in advance what you will do after a bad year in the market: e.g., no inflation adjustment or reverting to the minimum amount.
- Check when your RMDs will start and how much they might be at the current balance.
- Calculate the tax on planned withdrawals and decide from which accounts (traditional, Roth, regular) to withdraw in that year.
- You can use a free RMD calculator at investor.gov for your calculations.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is 4% a safe withdrawal rate today as well?
No one can guarantee that. The 1994 study showed that in the history of the U.S. market, 4% lasted at least 33 years with a portfolio of at least half in stocks. Today, it is a good starting point for discussion, but not a promise.
Can I withdraw 4% if I retire at age 55?
With a longer retirement, the risk increases. In Bengen's study, only 3% (up to about 3.5%) lasted 50 years in every case. Also, remember the additional 10% tax on withdrawals from an IRA before age 59.5.
Does RMD count towards my withdrawal rate?
Yes, it is part of the money withdrawn from savings. If the RMD is higher than what you need, you can invest the excess after tax.
Does Social Security count towards the 4%?
No. The rule applies to withdrawals from the savings portfolio. Social Security reduces the amount you need to withdraw from the portfolio.
Sources
| Source | Type | Status / Credibility |
|---|---|---|
| W. P. Bengen, "Determining Withdrawal Rates Using Historical Data", Journal of Financial Planning (1994, reprint 2004) | Study (original) | Source text, verified 10/23/2026 |
| IRS: Retirement plan and IRA required minimum distributions FAQs | Government (USA) | Official, verified 10/23/2026 |
| IRS Publication 590-B (Uniform Lifetime Table, 10% withholding, withdrawals before 59.5) | Government (USA) | Official, verified 10/23/2026 |
| IRS Publication 915: taxation of Social Security benefits | Government (USA) | Official, verified 10/23/2026 |
| IRS: Tax deductions for working Americans and seniors (additional $6,000 deduction) | Government (USA) | Official, verified 10/23/2026 |
| Editorial numerical examples ($600,000, 3% inflation, $500,000 balance) | Calculation | Own calculations, not a forecast |
As of October 23, 2026. This guide is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment, tax, or legal advice. The 4% rule is a benchmark from historical studies, not a guarantee. Check tax thresholds and RMD age before making decisions, as regulations change.
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first!