Skip to main content

Car Accident in the USA: What to Do Step by Step, Insurance, and Lawyer

What to do after an accident in the USA: safety, call 911 for injuries, exchange information, take photos, do not admit fault. Report to the insurer, MV-104 report in New York within 10 days, hit-and-run, uninsured driver, when to get a lawyer, and statutes of limitations in NY, NJ, CA, and FL.

In short: after an accident, stop, secure the scene, and check if anyone is injured. Call 911 for injuries. Exchange information with the other driver, take photos, do not admit fault, and report the claim to your insurer as soon as possible. In New York, accidents with injuries or property damage exceeding 1000 USD must also be reported to the DMV within 10 days. Depending on the state, you usually have 2 or 3 years to file a lawsuit.

A car accident is stressful, and in the first minutes, you need to make several decisions that will later weigh on insurance and compensation. Below, step by step: what to do at the scene, what to do in the following days, when to seek a lawyer, and how much time you have for claims. Regulations vary between states. As an example, we mainly provide information for New York, where many Polish people live.

At the Accident Scene Step by Step

1. Safety

  • Stop. Leaving the scene of an accident is a violation, and if someone is injured or killed, it is a crime (this is the case in New York, among others).
  • Turn on your hazard lights. If possible, move off the roadway.
  • Mark the scene with reflectors or flares if you have them, but be cautious of leaking fuel.
  • Exit the vehicle only if it is safe, and stand away from traffic. On the highway, do not stand in the lane or between cars.
  • Check if anyone is injured. Do not move an unconscious person unless they are in immediate danger, such as from a fire.

2. Call 911

If someone is injured or killed, you must call the police immediately. Also call 911 if cars are blocking the road, something is on fire, or the other driver refuses to provide information. In English, it is sufficient to say: “I had a car accident at [address or intersection]. Someone is hurt.”

A police report is very helpful for processing the claim. If the police arrive, ask for the report number and the officer's name.

3. Do Not Admit Fault

Determining fault is the role of the police, insurers, and, in case of a dispute, the court. Statements made at the scene can later end up in the claim file.

  • Avoid: “I'm sorry, it was my fault,” “I didn't see you,” “I was going too fast.”
  • Safe phrases: “Are you okay?”, “Let's exchange information,” “I'll report it to my insurance.”

Do not discuss the details of the incident with the other driver. Calmly describe the facts to the police without guessing.

4. Exchange Information

In New York, even for property damage alone, drivers must exchange information. Collect the following from each driver:

  1. name, address, and phone number,
  2. driver's license number (take a photo of the document),
  3. license plate number and details from the registration,
  4. insurance company name, policy number, and effective date (photo of the insurance card),
  5. make, model, and color of the vehicle.

From witnesses, take their name, phone number, and a brief note of what they saw, which will be helpful later.

5. Photos and Notes

  • damage to all vehicles, both close-up and from a distance,
  • position of vehicles, signs, signals, skid marks,
  • weather, lighting, road conditions,
  • visible injuries,
  • time and exact location. Write it down immediately, as it can be difficult to recall after a few days.

Special Situations

Hit-and-Run

  • Write down the license plate number, even if partial, as well as the color, make, and direction of escape.
  • Call the police immediately.
  • Your insurance may cover the damage if you have uninsured motorist protection (uninsured motorist, UM/UIM) or collision coverage. Check your policy terms. In some states, UM is mandatory.

The Other Driver is Uninsured

Here, UM/UIM protection from your policy also helps. You can sue the driver civilly, but if they have no insurance or assets, collecting on a judgment may be difficult. We explain how types of insurance work in the guide car insurance in the USA.

You Were Driving on a Polish License

How long you can drive on a foreign license depends on the state and whether you are a tourist or a resident. Check the rules on your state's DMV website. A description of obtaining an American driver's license can be found in the guide how to pass the driving test in the USA.

You Do Not Have Regularized Status

Do not flee the scene of the accident, as this is a separate and serious violation. Provide the information you must give when exchanging information and cooperate in securing the scene. For other matters, you can say that you want to speak with a lawyer (“I would like to speak with a lawyer”). Polish citizens can also seek assistance from the Polish consulate.

Post-Accident Reporting

Insurer

Report the claim to your insurer as soon as possible, either by phone or through the app. Policies require prompt reporting, and delays can complicate payment. Do not sign anything at the scene and keep all receipts: towing, taxi, medications.

DMV in New York

In New York, a driver must file a MV-104 report with the DMV within 10 days if someone was injured or killed in the accident or if property damage to one person (including your own) exceeds 1000 USD. Reporting to the insurer does not replace this requirement. Failing to file a report is a misdemeanor and may result in suspension of your driver's license or registration. Other states have their own thresholds and deadlines, so check them with your DMV.

Doctor

See a doctor within a few days, even if you feel fine. Whiplash and other injuries can manifest symptoms later. Keep all medical documentation. If you delay, the insurer may argue that the injury was not related to the accident.

When a Lawyer is Needed

For minor fender-benders without injuries, usually, the insurer is sufficient. Consult a personal injury lawyer when:

  • there are serious injuries: hospitalization, surgery, long rehabilitation,
  • the other party has a lawyer or their insurer pressures you for a recorded statement,
  • fault is disputed,
  • the compensation offer seems low,
  • the at-fault party fled or was uninsured,
  • someone died.

Many personal injury lawyers work on a contingency fee basis, meaning they take a percentage of the amount recovered. Before signing a contract, ask what that percentage is and who pays the costs if you lose. You can check a lawyer's license in your state through the state bar registry.

What Not to Do

ErrorWhy It Harms
Talking to the other party's lawyer or insurer without preparationYour words may be used to determine fault
Giving a recorded statement to the other party's insurerYou do not have to provide it immediately; first, talk to your insurer or lawyer
Signing a release without readingIt closes the door to further claims, even if the injury turns out to be more serious
Delaying a visit to the doctorIt becomes harder to prove the connection between the injury and the accident
Posting photos and comments on social mediaThe insurer may use them against you
Rushing to accept the first offerWith injuries, treatment costs may still rise

Statutes of Limitations

A lawsuit for damages must be filed before the statute of limitations expires. It is usually counted from the date of the accident. Examples:

StatePersonal InjuryProperty Damage
New York3 years3 years
New Jersey2 yearscheck with a lawyer
California2 years3 years
Florida2 years (for negligence claims arising after March 24, 2023; previously 4 years)2 years (as above)

There are exceptions, such as for minors, claims against public institutions, and wrongful death cases. Do not wait until the last minute, as evidence and witnesses may disappear over time.

If you received a ticket after the accident, read the guide traffic ticket in the USA. If the car is a total loss, the text how to buy a car in the USA will be useful.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I have to call the police for a minor accident?

It depends on the state. In New York, the police must be called if someone is injured or killed, and for property damage alone, you must exchange information and, if the damage exceeds 1000 USD, file a MV-104 report within 10 days. A police report still facilitates the claims process.

Does saying “sorry” mean I admit fault?

It does not determine the case, but such words may be recorded and used in determining fault. It is safer to ask if everyone is okay and exchange information.

How much time do I have to file a lawsuit after an accident?

In New York, 3 years; in New Jersey and California, 2 years for personal injuries; in Florida, 2 years for negligence claims arising after March 24, 2023. There are exceptions to these rules, so clarify the details with a lawyer.

Who pays if the at-fault party fled?

Most often, your own policy, if you have uninsured motorist or collision coverage. Without them, you may be left with the costs, so check your policy in advance.

Sources

SourceTypeStatus / Credibility
NY DMV: Driver's Manual, Chapter 12 (Traffic Accident)State agency websiteOfficial, verified 10/23/2026
NY DMV: MV-104 ReportState agency websiteOfficial
NY CPLR 214: 3-Year StatuteState law (NY)Official text
New Jersey P.L. 2019, c. 120 (N.J.S. 2A:14-2)State law (NJ)Official text
California Courts: Statutes of LimitationsState court website (CA)Official
Florida Statutes 95.11State law (FL)Official text, 2025 edition
Laws of Florida, ch. 2023-15 (Change of Deadline, Section 28)State law (FL)Official text

Status as of October 23, 2026. This guide is informational and does not constitute legal or insurance advice. Responsibilities after an accident, reporting thresholds, and statutes of limitations vary between states and have exceptions. In cases of injury, disputes over fault, or contact with the police regarding immigration status, consult a licensed lawyer in your state.

Related topics:

Was this guide helpful?

Help others – share your experience

Answer one question below. Your answer will help people in similar situations.

What were your first steps after a car accident in the USA? What did you do first?

Your response will be reviewed before publication.

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Be the first!


Add a comment

Log in to skip email verification, or comment as guest:

Comment may be moderated before publishing.