Skip to main content

Sole proprietorship, LLC, S-Corp or C-Corp – which business form to choose in the USA (2026)

A comparison of business forms in the USA for the Polish diaspora: liability, federal taxes (self-employment tax, S-Corp, C-Corp 21%, QBI), EIN, BOI, fees in New York and New Jersey, licenses, and why owning a business does not grant the right to work – with an interactive decision-making flowchart.

In brief
  • Sole proprietorship is created automatically, but you are personally liable for the company's debts with all your assets.
  • LLC is a legal form from the state. A single-member LLC is taxed by default on Schedule C, while a multi-member LLC is taxed as a partnership (Form 1065, K-1).
  • S-Corp is a tax election (Form 2553): max. 100 shareholders, one class of stock, no nonresident aliens.
  • C-Corp pays a federal tax of 21% on profits, and dividends are taxed again at the owner's level.
  • The self-employment tax is 15.3%; the portion for Social Security (12.4%) in 2026 applies to income up to $184,500.
  • As of August 14, 2026, companies established in the USA are exempt from BOI reporting to FinCEN.
  • Establishing or owning a business does not grant the right to work in the USA. To work in your own business, you need the appropriate immigration status.

Most Polish-owned businesses in the USA – cleaning, renovations, construction, trucking, services – start as a sole proprietorship. Sooner or later, the question arises: LLC, corporation, or maybe S-Corp? This guide organizes the four most common forms: sole proprietorship, LLC, S-Corp, and C-Corp. It describes how each affects your liability for debts, federal taxes, and formalities, and suggests what to ask your advisor.

As of October 23, 2026. State regulations vary – examples from NY and NJ are for illustration only.

Key distinction

Legal form (sole proprietorship, LLC, corporation) is determined by state law and primarily affects liability. Tax treatment (Schedule C, partnership, S-Corp, C-Corp) is determined by IRS regulations and your choices on forms. You do not register S-Corp at the state level – it is an IRS election. According to the SBA, an LLC can be taxed as an S-Corp or C-Corp.

Liability: what really protects LLCs and corporations

Sole proprietorship – no boundary between business and home

The SBA states that a sole proprietorship does not create a separate entity. The assets and liabilities of the business are not separate from your personal ones, so you are personally liable for the debts and obligations of the business. A business creditor can therefore reach your personal assets. The SBA considers this form reasonable mainly for low-risk activities and during the idea-testing phase.

LLC and corporation – protection “in most cases”

The SBA states that an LLC protects against personal liability “in most cases”: in the event of LLC bankruptcy or a lawsuit against it, your personal car, home, and savings are usually not at risk. A corporation is a separate legal entity that is responsible for its own obligations, and according to the SBA, it provides the strongest protection for owners. However, this comes with more formalities.

Protection has important exceptions (general description – details depend on state law):

  • Personal guarantees. Banks, equipment and truck lessors, landlords, or material suppliers often require the owner to sign a personal guarantee. In this case, you are personally liable for that debt, even if you have an LLC.
  • Your own actions. A company usually does not protect you from liability for damages you caused personally, e.g., through your own negligence on a construction site.
  • “Piercing the corporate veil.” This is a doctrine under which a court may, in exceptional circumstances, disregard the separateness of the company and hold the owner liable. Typical warning signs include mixing company and personal funds, insufficient capital relative to risk, and neglecting formalities.
Protection starts with a bank account

A separate business account, contracts signed in the name of the LLC (with the full company name), invoices to the company, and liability insurance are the simplest ways to ensure that LLC protection is not a fiction.

Federal taxes: how each form is taxed

Sole proprietorship and single-member LLC: Schedule C and self-employment tax

You report income and expenses on Schedule C of Form 1040, and from the profit, you additionally calculate the self-employment tax on Schedule SE. According to the IRS:

  • the self-employment tax rate is 15.3%: 12.4% for Social Security and 2.9% for Medicare;
  • you file Schedule SE if your net earnings from self-employment were at least $400;
  • the portion for Social Security applies only to income up to the limit (wage base). For 2026, the limit is $184,500 (IRS, Publication 15 for 2026; in 2025 it was $176,100). The Medicare portion has no limit;
  • above the threshold – $200,000 for single filers, $250,000 for married couples filing jointly – the Additional Medicare Tax 0.9% applies;
  • you can deduct half of the self-employment tax (“employer-equivalent portion”) when calculating your adjusted gross income (AGI). This reduces your income tax but not the self-employment tax itself.

A single-member LLC is, for IRS purposes, a disregarded entity – its activities are reported on your return just like a sole proprietorship. However, the IRS notes that for payroll taxes and some excise taxes, a single-member LLC is treated as a separate entity. If you hire employees, the LLC reports them under its own name and EIN. For carriers, it is important that the same applies to, among others, Form 2290 (heavy vehicle use tax).

Multi-member LLC: partnership, Form 1065, and K-1

Domestic LLCs with at least two members are treated by the IRS as a partnership, unless they file Form 8832 and elect to be taxed as a corporation. A partnership files an informational return Form 1065 each year, but does not pay income tax itself – the profit or loss “passes through” to the partners. Each receives a Schedule K-1 and reports their share on their own return. The IRS emphasizes that partners are not employees of the partnership and should not receive a W-2 form. Among the forms for partners, the IRS also lists Schedule SE, as the share of profit from the business usually is subject to self-employment tax.

A common situation in Polish families is a married couple running a cleaning business together. Spouses as two members of the LLC are generally considered a partnership. The IRS provides special rules for spouses owning an LLC as community property in states that recognize it. Discuss this configuration with your advisor.

S-Corp: salary + profit not subject to self-employment tax

An S-Corp generally does not pay federal income tax on its profits – they pass through to the shareholders (K-1) and are taxed at their rates. The IRS notes that an S-Corp may pay tax at the corporate level on certain built-in gains and some passive income.

Conditions according to the IRS – the company must:

  • be a domestic corporation or a domestic entity that can elect to be taxed as a corporation (e.g., LLC);
  • have only permitted shareholders: individuals, certain trusts, and estates. Shareholders cannot be partnerships, corporations, or nonresident aliens;
  • have no more than 100 shareholders; spouses (and family members under §1361(c)(1)(B)) can be counted as one;
  • have only one class of stock – differences in voting rights are allowed, but rights to distributions and to assets upon liquidation must be identical;
  • not be an excluded corporation (e.g., certain financial institutions and insurers).

Election deadline. Form 2553 must be signed by all shareholders. It must be filed no later than 2 months and 15 days from the beginning of the tax year for which the election is to apply, or at any time during the preceding year. According to IRS instructions, an eligible entity (e.g., LLC) that meets the conditions and files Form 2553 does not need to separately file Form 8832. There is a relief procedure for late elections with reasonable cause.

Reasonable compensation. This is the crux of S-Corp. The IRS requires that an S-Corp pays a working shareholder reasonable compensation for their work, before paying them other funds (distributions). Salary goes through payroll: in 2026, the Social Security tax is 6.2% on the employer side and 6.2% on the employee side (up to $184,500), and Medicare is 1.45% + 1.45% with no limit. The IRS considers factors such as experience, duties, time devoted to the company, and what similar companies pay for similar work.

What is the “savings” of S-Corp (interpretation)

The above rules lead to a mechanism that advisors talk about. The owner of a single-member LLC pays self-employment tax on the entire profit. The owner of an S-Corp pays payroll taxes on a reasonable salary, and on the remaining portion of profit paid as a distribution – they do not. However, there are costs (payroll, Form 1120-S filing, accounting, state taxes), so with low profits, the savings may be negligible. Calculate this with a CPA or Enrolled Agent.

Attention to states. The SBA reminds that not all states treat S-Corps the same. Some tax S-Corp profits above a certain threshold, while others do not recognize the S-Corp election at all and treat the company as a C-Corp. Check your state’s rules on the state department of revenue website.

C-Corp: 21% and double taxation

According to §11(b) Internal Revenue Code, the corporate income tax rate is 21% on taxable income – a single rate with no brackets (the instructions for Form 1120 instruct to multiply income by 0.21). When the corporation pays out profits as dividends, the shareholder pays tax again. Qualified dividends are taxed at lower rates like capital gains: 0%, 15%, or 20%, depending on income (the thresholds change every year). Non-qualified dividends are taxed as ordinary income. According to the SBA, C-Corp is more suitable for companies seeking investors or planning to sell.

QBI deduction (§199A) – after changes from 2025

The deduction for qualified business income (Qualified Business Income, QBI) allows owners of sole proprietorships, LLCs taxed as partnerships, and S-Corps to deduct up to 20% of QBI, with limitations depending on income and type of business. According to the IRS, income earned by C-Corp or employee wages do not qualify for this deduction. Therefore, for S-Corp, the profit counts, not your salary.

Previously, §199A was set to expire after December 31, 2025. The Pub. L. 119-21 of 2025 (the so-called One Big Beautiful Bill Act) replaced this provision with a new subsection (i). There is no expiration date, and for tax years beginning after 2025, there is a minimum deduction of $400 for a taxpayer with at least $1,000 of QBI from a business in which they materially participate. The full amount of the deduction depends on income and type of business.

Tax comparison for an owner working in the business

IssueSole prop / single-member LLCLLC as partnershipS-CorpC-Corp
Tax at the company levelNoNo (informational return)Generally no (exceptions: built-in gains, some passive income)Yes, 21%
How money comes to youAll profit is your incomeShare of profit per K-1Salary (W-2) + share of profit per K-1Salary (W-2) + dividends
Self-employment taxOn all profit (15.3% up to SS limit)Usually on share of profit from businessNone; payroll taxes on salaryNone; payroll taxes on salary
QBI deductionPossiblePossiblePossible (on profit, not salary)No
Nonresident alien as ownerPossible; LLC wholly owned by a foreign person may need to file Form 5472Possible (obligations with foreign partner discussed with advisor)Not allowedPossible
FormalitiesLeastMediumMany (payroll, 1120-S)Most

Which form suits your business?

Is any of the owners a nonresident alien for IRS purposes?

A foreigner is a tax resident if they meet the green card test or substantial presence test.

  • Yes – at least one owner is a nonresident
  • No – all are U.S. citizens or tax residents

S-Corp is out – LLC or C-Corp remain

A nonresident alien cannot be a shareholder of an S-Corp. An LLC wholly owned by a foreign person may need to file Form 5472 (penalty for non-filing: $25,000). Owning a business does not grant the right to work. Discuss this with a CPA or Enrolled Agent knowledgeable in international taxes and an immigration attorney.

How many owners will there be?

  • One (me)
  • Two or more (e.g., spouses, partners)

Most often: multi-member LLC (partnership)

Liability protection, reporting through Form 1065 and K-1. Draft an operating agreement. With high, stable profits and meeting conditions, consider S-Corp – discuss this with a CPA or Enrolled Agent.

Does the work carry real liability risk?

For example, employees, working in clients' homes, heavy equipment, trucks.

  • Minimal – minor services, testing an idea
  • Yes, the risk is significant

A sole proprietorship may suffice to start

Least formalities, but you are liable with all your assets. Consider liability insurance, and LLC when employees or larger contracts arise.

Is profit stable and high enough that after paying yourself a market salary, there is a clear surplus?

  • No or I don't know yet
  • Yes

Most often: single-member LLC (taxed as Schedule C)

Liability protection with simple reporting. You can consider S-Corp later when profits increase – check this with a CPA or Enrolled Agent.

Do you plan to leave most of the profit in the business, seek investors, or sell the business?

  • No – I want to distribute profits regularly
  • Yes

To consider: LLC taxed as S-Corp

Possible savings on self-employment tax, but with reasonable salary through payroll, higher accounting costs, and depending on state rules. Calculate this with a CPA or Enrolled Agent.

To consider: C-Corp

21% at the company level when profits remain in the company – but dividends are taxed a second time and there is no QBI. Decision for CPA, Enrolled Agent, and attorney.

EIN – the company's tax number

The EIN (Employer Identification Number) is issued by the IRS for free. The IRS warns against websites that charge for this service. You can use the online form if:

  • the company was established in the USA (or in U.S. territories) and has its principal place of business there;
  • you are the “responsible party” – the person controlling the entity – or their authorized representative;
  • you have a SSN or ITIN of the responsible party.

One responsible person can obtain a maximum of one EIN per day. If the headquarters is outside the USA, the application is submitted by phone, fax, or mail. EIN is needed, among other things, for hiring employees, operating a partnership or corporation, and filing excise taxes. When a single-member LLC can do without an EIN – see FAQ. You can read about ITIN in the guide ITIN – tax number.

BOI (Corporate Transparency Act) – status as of 2026

The status of the obligation to report beneficial owners (Beneficial Ownership Information, BOI) according to FinCEN:

  • On March 21, 2025, FinCEN announced and on March 26, 2025, published an interim final rule that exempted all entities created in the USA and their beneficiaries from reporting;
  • On August 11, 2026, FinCEN issued a final rule that solidifies this exemption. It took effect on August 14, 2026;
  • U.S. companies do not need to file BOI reports. The obligation applies only to certain foreign companies registered to do business in the USA, and even they do not report beneficiaries who are “U.S. persons.”
Beware of false solicitations

If you receive letters or emails demanding payment for “mandatory BOI reporting” for your LLC established in the USA, check the legal status directly on fincen.gov.

Registration in the State: Examples from NY and NJ

LLCs and corporations are established in the state – usually through the Secretary of State or the appropriate office. The SBA reminds that a business will typically need to register in every state where it operates. Fees and periodic obligations vary in each state. Below are some examples from official websites:

StateWhat You Need to Know (LLC)Source
New YorkFee for Articles of Organization: 200 USD. Within 120 days of the effective date of the Articles, the LLC must publish a notice in two newspapers, and then submit a Certificate of Publication (state fee 50 USD; the cost of the notices is determined by the newspapers). Failure to publish results in the suspension of the LLC's authority to conduct business. A Biennial Statement is filed every two years (fee 9 USD).NY DOS – Articles, NY DOS – Publication
New JerseyCertificate of formation LLC: 100 USD. Annual Report LLC: 75 USD.NJ Division of Revenue – Fees
IllinoisWe were unable to open the current fee schedule on the state website. Check the fees for forming an LLC and the annual report on the Secretary of State Illinois website.ilsos.gov

Sales Tax, Licenses, and Permits

The legal form does not exempt from licenses. According to the SBA, most small businesses require a combination of federal, state, and local licenses, and the requirements and fees depend on the type of business and location. At the federal level, the SBA lists, among others, transportation (e.g., oversized vehicles – permits are issued by the state, and the Department of Transportation indicates the appropriate office). Registration for sales tax and state tax number is handled at the state department of revenue (Department of Revenue or Taxation). Whether your service is subject to sales tax depends on the state. A specific example for cleaning businesses can be found in the guide on cleaning business in the USA.

Business and Work Authorization – Important for Immigrants

Establishing a company and having shares in it is different from work authorization. USCIS describes separate pathways for entrepreneurs, each with its own conditions. Examples include:

  • B-1 (business visitor): allows for negotiating contracts or renting an office when starting a business, but does not permit working for the company in the USA or running it;
  • E-2 (investor from a treaty country): requires a substantial investment and at least 50% ownership or operational control, and the business cannot be "marginal";
  • permanent resident (Green Card): can work in the USA without restrictions.

Our interpretation of these rules: owning an LLC or corporation does not, by itself, grant the right to work, and performing work for your own company requires a status that allows it. Only an immigration attorney can assess the implications for your status – USCIS also suggests consulting with an attorney. Taxes are a separate issue – you can read about the ITIN in a separate guide.

For Comparison: Polish JDG and Sp. z o.o.

For reference only, without legal equivalence: Sole proprietorship resembles a sole trader: no separate entity and liability for all assets. LLC and corporation serve a similar role to a Sp. z o.o., separating business assets from personal ones. However, in the USA, there is flexibility in choosing the method of taxation – the same LLC can be taxed as a "sole proprietorship", as a partnership, as an S-Corp, or as a C-Corp. The Polish Sp. z o.o. has its own rules regarding management liability – we describe them in the guide how to protect personal assets from business debts.

A Polish company registered to operate in a state in the USA is a foreign company – according to FinCEN, such entities may still be subject to BOI reporting.

Myths and Facts

MythFact
"An LLC pays lower taxes than a sole proprietorship"A single-member LLC is taxed the same as a sole proprietorship by default (Schedule C, self-employment tax). The difference mainly concerns liability.
"In an S-Corp, I can set a minimal salary for myself and take the rest as profit"The IRS requires a reasonable salary before profit distributions and may reclassify distributions as salary subject to payroll taxes.
"Since I have an LLC, my home is safe in any situation"Protection does not cover, among other things, debts with personal guarantees or damages you cause personally. A court may also disregard the separateness of the company if you mix finances.
"Since I have a business, I can work in it without authorization"Owning a business does not equate to the right to work. A status that allows it is required.

Frequently Asked Questions

At what profit does it make sense to have an S-Corp?

There is no official threshold. The savings depend on what salary will be considered "reasonable" in your industry, how much additional accounting and payroll costs, and how your state treats S-Corps. Ask a CPA or Enrolled Agent to calculate both scenarios based on your numbers.

Can I change the structure later?

Yes. A sole proprietor can establish an LLC, and an LLC can choose to be taxed as a corporation (Form 8832) or S-Corp (Form 2553), adhering to IRS deadlines. However, changing the structure may have tax implications – the SBA warns about such consequences when making changes – and may require a new EIN. Plan it with an advisor before the start of the tax year.

I have a Green Card – can I have an S-Corp?

In principle, yes. A Green Card holder meets the Green Card test and is a tax resident of the USA, and the restriction applies to nonresident aliens. All other shareholders must also meet the conditions.

As an LLC owner, can I employ myself on a W-2 in my own company?

In an LLC taxed as a partnership – no: the IRS indicates that partners are not employees and do not receive W-2s. The owner receives a W-2 salary when the LLC elects to be taxed as a corporation (S-Corp or C-Corp). The difference between W-2 and 1099 is explained in the guide on W-2 and 1099.

Does a single-member LLC need an EIN?

Not always. According to the IRS, an LLC without employees and without excise taxes can use the owner's number. In practice, an EIN may be needed for a bank account or for state reasons, and obtaining it is free.

Owner Liability: What to Check Before Signing

LLCs and corporations are separate entities, but personal guarantees for loans, leases, or leases can create separate obligations for the person who signed them. Before signing, check whether the guarantee covers only the principal, or also interest and costs, what the limit is, and when it expires. The law of the relevant state and the content of the document matter.

Separately, one should assess their own actions and tax obligations. The IRS explains that Trust Fund Recovery Penalty may apply to the person responsible for collecting or paying certain employment taxes who willfully failed to perform that duty. The mere function or ownership of shares does not replace the analysis of statutory prerequisites.

A practical example: a bank lends money to a company but also requires the owner's signature on a personal guarantee. Even if the loan agreement is with the LLC, the scope of personal liability must be determined from the content of the guarantee. In case of liquidity issues, it is advisable to quickly consult the agreement and obligations with a lawyer and accountant in the relevant state.

Related Guides

Sources

SourceTypeStatus / Credibility
IRS – Self-employment taxFederal AgencyPrimary; 15.3%, 400 USD, 0.9%
IRS – Publication 15 (2026)Federal AgencyPrimary; limit 184,500 USD
IRS – Single Member LLCFederal AgencyPrimary
IRS – PartnershipsFederal AgencyPrimary
IRS – S CorporationsFederal AgencyPrimary
IRS – Instructions for Form 2553Federal AgencyPrimary
IRS – S Corporation CompensationFederal AgencyPrimary
26 U.S.C. §11StatuteText of the statute (LII)
IRS – Instructions for Form 1120Federal AgencyPrimary
IRS – Topic 404 (Dividends)Federal AgencyPrimary
IRS – Topic 409 (Capital Gains)Federal AgencyPrimary
IRS – QBI DeductionFederal AgencyPrimary
26 U.S.C. §199AStatuteText after Pub. L. 119-21 (LII)
IRS – Get an EINFederal AgencyPrimary
IRS – Instructions for Form 5472Federal AgencyPrimary
IRS – Tax Residency StatusFederal AgencyPrimary
FinCEN – BOIFederal AgencyPrimary; status as of 11.08.2026
SBA – Business StructureFederal AgencyPrimary
SBA – Licenses and PermitsFederal AgencyPrimary
USCIS – EntrepreneursFederal AgencyPrimary
NY Department of StateState OfficePrimary
NJ Division of RevenueState OfficePrimary

As of October 23, 2026. This guide is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, tax, or immigration advice. Tax regulations and state fees change – consult with a CPA, Enrolled Agent, or attorney before choosing a business structure, and for status matters, consult an immigration attorney.

Was this guide helpful?

Help others – share your experience

Answer one question below. Your answer will help people in similar situations.

What type of business entity did you choose and why? What factors influenced your decision?

Your response will be reviewed before publication.

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Be the first!


Add a comment

Log in to skip email verification, or comment as guest:

Comment may be moderated before publishing.