- Receiving cash payments is legal. The problem arises when income is not reported on tax returns or when the employer does not report the employee.
- Self-employed individuals pay a self-employment tax of 15.3% (12.4% Social Security and 2.9% Medicare) if their net earnings are at least 400 USD in a year.
- Without reported earnings, you do not accumulate Social Security credits. You need 40 credits for retirement, and you can earn a maximum of 4 credits per year.
- Starting from payments for 2026, companies will issue 1099-NEC only for amounts of 2000 USD or more annually (previously 600 USD). Income below this threshold still needs to be reported.
- If you work as an employee and receive cash or a 1099, you have access to Form SS-8 and Form 8919.
- ITIN allows you to file taxes but does not grant the right to work or Social Security benefits.
This guide is for individuals who receive cash payments: in house cleaning, childcare, elder care, construction, kitchen work, or painting. We explain when such work is acceptable and when it violates the law, what you realistically lose, and how to get your taxes in order.
As of October 23, 2026, amounts and thresholds change annually, and some rules depend on the state. For immigration matters, always consult an immigration attorney.
What Does "Cash Work" Mean
"Cash work," "under the table," "off the books": these terms usually describe the same situation.
- The employer pays in cash or with a personal check.
- No W-2 or 1099 is issued.
- No income tax or FICA (Social Security and Medicare) is withheld.
- No unemployment insurance tax is paid, and often there is no workers' compensation policy.
Cash is Not the Problem; Hidden Income Is
When Cash Payments Are Acceptable
Many legally employed individuals receive cash. What matters is whether the income is visible to the tax authority:
- The employer issues a W-2 (if you are an employee) or a 1099-NEC (if you are an independent contractor),
- With a W-2, the employer withholds and pays taxes and FICA,
- When self-employed, you report all income on Form 1040 with Schedule C and pay self-employment tax (Schedule SE).
The threshold for 1099-NEC has changed. Public Law 119-21 raised it to 2000 USD annually from a single payer for payments starting in 2026, and from 2027, the amount may be indexed. For 2025, the threshold was still 600 USD. The absence of a form does not exempt you from taxes: according to the IRS, self-employment tax is owed when net earnings from self-employment are at least 400 USD.
When Lawbreaking Begins
- The employee does not report earnings on their tax return.
- The employer does not report payments and does not withhold required payroll taxes.
What are the consequences for an employee who has not reported income? For late filing, the IRS imposes a penalty of 5% of unpaid tax for each month, up to a total of 25%. If the underpayment is due to fraud, the civil penalty is 75% of that portion (26 U.S.C. 6663). Willful tax evasion is a crime under 26 U.S.C. 7201: fines up to 100,000 USD (up to 500,000 USD for corporations), up to 5 years in prison, or both penalties together.
What Employees Lose
Social Security Credits
This is a loss that is not immediately visible. The right to Social Security retirement benefits generally requires 40 "quarters of coverage," or credits (42 U.S.C. 414), and in one year, you can earn a maximum of 4 (42 U.S.C. 413). Credits are only earned from wages on which contributions were paid and which were reported under an SSN.
Without them, there is no Social Security retirement, disability benefits (SSDI), or family benefits after your death. According to Medicare.gov, Part A is free for individuals who (themselves or their spouse) have paid Medicare tax for at least 10 years. Others can purchase it: in 2026, for 311 or 565 USD per month.
You also do not have an employer-sponsored retirement plan (401(k)) or employer contributions.
Workplace Injury
An employee paid in cash is still an employee. In many states, they can claim workers' compensation, even if the employer did not report them, and states have funds for cases where the employer lacks a policy. In practice, however, the lack of paperwork makes it difficult to prove employment. Details for NY, NJ, and IL are described in the guide Workers' Compensation in the USA.
Unemployment
Unemployment benefits are calculated based on wages that the employer reported to the state. If you formally earned nothing, it is difficult to obtain them.
Credit, Rent, Car
For a mortgage, apartment rental, or car financing, you usually need to document income: with tax returns, W-2, or 1099, pay stubs. Cash without any documentation is a weak card in such negotiations.
Immigration Matters
- Affidavit of Support (I-864). The sponsor must include a transcript or a copy of the federal tax return for the last tax year. If they were required to file it and did not, USCIS instructions require them to first file the overdue returns with the IRS.
- Naturalization. According to the USCIS Policy Manual, failure to file required returns or pay taxes may prevent demonstrating "good moral character." Discrepancies between documents and returns can also be problematic.
What Employers Risk
Tax Penalties
- Failure to file W-2 or 1099 on time (forms required in 2026): 60, 130, or 340 USD for each form, depending on the delay, and for willful neglect, 680 USD. A separate penalty applies for failing to provide a copy to the employee.
- Late payroll tax payments: from 2% to 15% of the unpaid amount, depending on the delay.
- Trust Fund Recovery Penalty: the person responsible for payments (e.g., the owner) may be personally liable for an amount equal to the withheld but unpaid income tax and the employee portion of FICA.
- Criminal liability for tax evasion (26 U.S.C. 7201), as described above.
Lack of Workers' Compensation
An example from New York: according to WCB, the penalty for lacking a policy can reach 2000 USD for every 10 days without insurance, and the company may receive a stop work order. Lack of a policy with five or fewer employees is a violation punishable by a fine of 1000 to 5000 USD, and with more employees, it is a felony. Other states have their own penalties.
Minimum Wage and Overtime
The FLSA requires at least 1.5 times the rate for hours over 40 in a week (29 U.S.C. 207), if the employee is covered by the overtime provision. According to the Department of Labor (DOL) Wage and Hour Division, minimum wage and overtime are enforced regardless of whether the employee has documentation.
Form I-9
Every employer must complete an I-9 for each hired person. Penalties for hiring without authorization and for errors in I-9 are described in the guide Working in the USA Without Work Authorization.
How to Get Organized Step by Step
Answer a few questions, and you will see which path from the sections below suits you best.
I Work for Cash: Where to Start?
Do you have an SSN that allows you to work?
Does the client set your hours, method of work, and provide tools?
Will the employer agree to pay through payroll and issue a W-2?
- Yes
- No
Switch to W-2
The employer withholds taxes and your portion of FICA, and you accumulate Social Security credits. See section "Option 3."
Possible Misclassification
You can file Form SS-8 and report your portion of contributions on Form 8919. For unpaid wages, the DOL or state labor department can help. Be aware of the risk of losing your job. See section "When the Employer Refuses W-2 or 1099."
Report as self-employed
Keep track of income and expenses, file 1040 with Schedule C and SE, and pay quarterly estimated taxes. If you have a steady business, consider starting your own company. See sections on self-employment and LLC.
Taxes with ITIN, but be aware of limitations
ITIN is filed with W-7, usually together with the tax return. It does not grant the right to work or Social Security benefits. Before filing anything, consult an immigration attorney. See sections "Option 2" and "Individuals Without Status."
Four Paths to Legal Reporting
Option 1: Self-Employment (Schedule C)
For many people working for several clients, this is the simplest path:
- You keep a record of income: a notebook, calendar, bank deposit receipts.
- You file Form 1040 with Schedule C (profit or loss from business) and Schedule SE.
- You pay a self-employment tax of 15.3%. The Social Security portion (12.4%) applies in 2026 to total earnings up to 184,500 USD, while the Medicare portion (2.9%) has no limit.
- You can deduct half of the self-employment tax (the "employer" portion) from your income.
- You pay quarterly estimated taxes: April 15, June 15, September 15, and January 15 of the following year.
With an SSN, reported earnings build Social Security credits.
Option 2: ITIN for Individuals Without SSN
The IRS issues ITINs to individuals who have a tax obligation but cannot obtain an SSN. The W-7 application is usually submitted with the first tax return. The IRS notes that ITIN:
- does not grant or change immigration status,
- does not authorize legal work,
- does not provide rights to Social Security benefits or EITC.
More in the guide ITIN – Tax Number in the USA. The rules for the child tax credit are described in the guide Child Tax Credit in the USA 2026.
Option 3: Talk to Your Employer
Ask for:
- A W-2 if you are effectively an employee (the employer sets hours, method of work, provides tools),
- A 1099-NEC if you are genuinely acting as an independent contractor (from 2026 for payments of 2000 USD or more annually).
The employer often refuses because it incurs additional costs. Nevertheless, the conversation can be effective, especially for steady work with one family. An individual hiring domestic help (a nanny, caregiver) is required by the IRS to withhold and pay FICA if they pay one person at least 3000 USD in cash in 2026.
Option 4: Start Your Own Business (LLC)
If you are independently managing contracts (cleaning, painting), you can start a business: register in the state (fees depend on the state), obtain an EIN from the IRS, open a separate business account, issue invoices to clients, and pay quarterly estimated taxes. An LLC does not change the self-employment tax rate by itself. However, it provides order in paperwork and makes it easier to hire others. Details: How to Open an LLC in the USA and what type of business to choose.
When the Employer Refuses W-2 or 1099
Status Depends on Facts, Not Employer's Will
According to the IRS, whether someone is an employee is determined by control: whether the company has the right to direct what and how you do your work, who decides on the financial aspects of the work, and what the nature of the relationship is. The exact criteria are described in the guide W-2 vs 1099.
Form SS-8 and Form 8919
- Form SS-8 is a request to the IRS to determine status for payroll tax purposes. The IRS issues a decision to the company and sends a copy to the employee. Information from the application may reach the other party, so the employer will learn about the matter.
- Form 8919 allows you to calculate only your portion of contributions (6.2% Social Security and 1.45% Medicare) instead of the full 15.3%. If you do not yet have an IRS decision, you enter code G and file SS-8 no later than the date of filing your return.
According to IRS instructions, SS-8 is not a request for a tax refund. If the IRS classifies you as an employee, you are responsible for correcting your returns.
Unpaid Wages
For unpaid minimum wage or overtime, the complaint is accepted by the Wage and Hour Division (DOL) or the state labor department. The FLSA prohibits firing and other discrimination against an employee for filing a complaint, including verbal complaints (section 15(a)(3)). In New Jersey, the state labor department explicitly states that threatening to report an employee or their family to immigration authorities for filing a complaint is illegal retaliation. Despite these prohibitions, the risk of losing your job practically exists.
Individuals Without Status: Real Risks
- Tax Data and Immigration Authorities. Section 6103 of the tax code protects the confidentiality of tax data, but there are exceptions, including for criminal investigations by other federal agencies (6103(i)). Therefore, do not assume that information from the IRS will never reach another agency. Discuss the decision to file for ITIN and returns with an immigration attorney.
- Right to Payment. The DOL enforces minimum wage and overtime for work actually performed, regardless of status.
- Workplace Injury. In New York, according to WCB, citizenship and immigration status do not affect benefits, and Illinois law explicitly includes foreigners. Other states have their own rules.
- New Deductions for Tips and Overtime (2025–2028, PL 119-21) require an SSN valid for work. Individuals with ITIN will not benefit from them.
The consequences of working without authorization and using false documents are described in the guide Working in the USA Without Work Authorization.
Tips and Overtime Deductions for 2025-2028
Public Law 119-21 introduced two new deductions for the tax years 2025–2028:
- Tips: up to 25,000 USD annually in occupations where tips are customary. Both employees and self-employed individuals can benefit (for self-employed, the deduction cannot exceed net income from that activity).
- Overtime: up to 12,500 USD (25,000 USD for joint filing). Only "half" of the required FLSA rate of 1.5 is deductible, meaning the excess over the regular rate.
- Both deductions decrease with modified income above 150,000 USD (300,000 USD for joint filing), require an SSN valid for work, and spouses must file jointly.
Receiving cash without any documentation complicates proving tips and overtime.
Where to Seek Help
- VITA: an IRS program offering free assistance in filling out returns, including for individuals earning typically up to about 70,244 USD annually and those with limited English proficiency.
- Low Income Taxpayer Clinics (LITC): according to the IRS, independent clinics that represent low-income individuals in disputes with the IRS and inform about taxpayer rights in various languages.
- Wage and Hour Division (DOL) and state labor departments: complaints about unpaid wages.
- State Workers' Compensation Boards: in New York, WCB offers free language assistance, including in Polish, at (877) 632-4996.
- Immigration Attorney or Accredited Representative: before any decision that may have immigration consequences.
Practical Tips
- Start filing as soon as possible. It is better to submit overdue returns with the help of VITA or LITC.
- Keep a work calendar and record every payment. In a wage dispute, these are your proofs.
- Regularly deposit cash into an account to leave a trace of income.
- Self-employment tax is painful, but with an SSN, it provides Social Security credits and Medicare eligibility.
- If you have many clients, consider starting your own business and proper accounting.
- After an accident, see a doctor and state that it is a workplace accident. The emergency room is required to examine and stabilize you regardless of payment ability (EMTALA).
- Do not rush to sign any "settlements" from the employer. First, talk to a lawyer.
Related Guides
- W-2 vs 1099 in the USA: Employee or Contractor
- Workers' Compensation in the USA: Workplace Accident
- Working in the USA Without Work Authorization
- ITIN: Tax Number in the USA
- Cleaning Business in the USA
Frequently Asked Questions
Is receiving cash illegal?
No. Cash is just a form of payment. It is illegal to hide income from the IRS: not reporting it on a return or not reporting an employee by the employer.
Do I have to report income for which I did not receive a 1099?
Yes. The 1099-NEC form is the payer's obligation (from payments for 2026 starting at 2000 USD annually). Your obligation to report income exists regardless of whether the form was received. Self-employment tax is owed on net earnings of 400 USD or more in a year.
What is the self-employment tax in 2026?
15.3%: 12.4% for Social Security on total earnings up to 184,500 USD and 2.9% for Medicare with no limit. You can deduct half of this tax from your income.
Do I earn Social Security credits with ITIN?
According to the IRS, ITIN does not provide rights to Social Security benefits. Credits are counted by the Social Security Administration based on earnings reported under an SSN.
What to do if I work as an employee and the employer pays me cash?
You can file Form SS-8 with the IRS, and when filing, Form 8919 with code G, to pay only your portion of contributions. For unpaid wages, file a complaint with the DOL or state labor department. Be aware that the employer will learn about the application.
Sources
| Source | Type | Status / Credibility |
|---|---|---|
| IRS: Self-employment tax | Federal Agency | Original, updated 06/27/2026 |
| IRS Topic 751: Social Security and Medicare withholding | Federal Agency | Original, limit 184,500 USD for 2026 |
| IRS: Instructions for Forms 1099-MISC and 1099-NEC | Federal Agency | Original, threshold 2000 USD from 2026 |
| IRS: Information return penalties | Federal Agency | Original, amounts for 2026 |
| IRS: Failure to deposit penalty | Federal Agency | Original |
| IRS: Trust Fund Recovery Penalty | Federal Agency | Original |
| IRS: Failure to file penalty | Federal Agency | Original |
| 26 U.S.C. 7201 and 26 U.S.C. 6663 | Statute (GPO) | Original |
| 26 U.S.C. 6103 | Statute (GPO) | Original |
| 42 U.S.C. 414 and 42 U.S.C. 413 | Statute (GPO) | Original |
| Medicare.gov: Medicare costs | Federal Agency | Original, amounts for 2026 |
| IRS: ITIN | Federal Agency | Original |
| IRS: Instructions for Form SS-8 and Form 8919 | Federal Agency | Original |
| IRS: No tax on tips and IRS: overtime deduction FAQ | Federal Agency | Original |
| 26 U.S.C. 224 and 26 U.S.C. 225 | Statute (text in LII Cornell) | Statute text, term until the end of 2028 |
| IRS Topic 756: Household employees | Federal Agency | Original, threshold 3000 USD for 2026 |
| IRS: Estimated tax FAQ | Federal Agency | Original |
| 29 U.S.C. 207 (FLSA, overtime) | Statute (GPO) | Original |
| DOL WHD Fact Sheet #48 and Fact Sheet #77A | Federal Agency | Original |
| NJDOL: Our commitment (rights of immigrant workers) | State Agency (NJ) | Original |
| NY WCB: Violations of Workers' Compensation Law | State Agency (NY) | Original |
| NY WCB: guide for injured parties (in Polish) | State Agency (NY) | Original |
| USCIS: Instructions for Form I-864 | Federal Agency | Original |
| USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 12, Part F, Chapter 5 | Federal Agency | Original |
| IRS: VITA and TCE | Federal Agency | Original |
| CMS: EMTALA | Federal Agency | Original |
As of October 23, 2026. This guide is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, tax, or immigration advice. Amounts and thresholds change annually, and many rules depend on the state. For specific matters, consult a tax advisor, VITA or LITC program, or an attorney.
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first!